Taxability of life insurance maturity proceeds turns on section 10(10D) threshold and no deduction for premium paid.

Where a life insurance policy falls within section 10(10D) and the premium payable exceeds the statutory 20% threshold of the actual sum assured, the maturity proceeds are taxable as gross income in the hands of the insured. The provision does not permit reduction of the taxable maturity receipt by deducting the insurance premium, and the premium is not treated as expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively to earn the proceeds. The note therefore states that the full maturity amount is chargeable to tax without any set-off for the premium paid.

---

---

Issues: Whether the maturity proceeds of a life insurance policy were taxable where the premium payable exceeded 20% of the actual sum assured, and whether the insurance premium could be deducted from the maturity amount while computing taxable income.

Analysis: The policy was issued within the period covered by section 10(10D) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and the premium payable exceeded the prescribed threshold of 20% of the sum assured. In such a case, the maturity proceeds are taxable in the hands of the insured. The provision brings to tax the gross maturity receipts and does not contemplate reduction of the premium paid from the maturity amount. The premium was also not treated as expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for earning the maturity proceeds.

Conclusion: The maturity proceeds were rightly brought to tax, and the assessee was not entitled to exclude the insurance premium from the taxable receipt. The issue is decided in favour of the Revenue.

Ratio Decidendi: Where section 10(10D) applies and the premium exceeds the statutory threshold, the entire maturity receipt is taxable as gross income and no deduction of the insurance premium is permissible.

---