Under-valuation of export sales cannot justify addition without tangible evidence of undisclosed receipts or physical verification.

An addition for alleged under-valuation of export sales was found unsustainable where the valuation report was prepared only from documents on record, without physical inspection of the goods. The export transactions had already been appraised by customs, no objection was raised to the declared value, and there was no independent evidence of undisclosed receipts or under-invoiced sales. On those facts, the marginal valuation difference was treated as a notional estimate rather than a reliable basis for income addition, and the Revenue's challenge failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the addition made on account of alleged under-valuation of export sales, based on a valuation report obtained without physical inspection of the goods and without independent evidence of undisclosed receipts, was sustainable.

Analysis: The addition rested on a valuation exercise undertaken from bills and particulars supplied on record, without physical verification of the exported goods. The export transactions had already been subjected to customs appraisal, and no doubt had been raised by the customs authorities regarding the declared value. The valuation difference was marginal and, on the facts found, remained an estimate unsupported by tangible material showing receipt of undisclosed income or under-invoiced sales. In such circumstances, the addition could not be sustained merely on a notional valuation basis.

Conclusion: The addition for alleged under-valuation of export sales was rightly deleted and the Revenue's challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The assessee succeeded on the substantive issue, and the Revenue appeal did not warrant interference.

Ratio Decidendi: A notional addition for under-valuation of sales cannot be sustained in the absence of tangible evidence of undisclosed receipts, and a valuation report based only on documents without physical verification cannot by itself justify an income addition.

---