Field Service Engineers' Repair Services and Spare Parts Storage Create Fixed Establishment Under GST Section 2(71)

The AAR, Odisha held that the applicant's repair and maintenance services provided through Field Service Engineers in Odisha, along with the storage of spare parts and tool kits at the applicant's location, constitute a fixed establishment in Odisha. The establishment is not temporary due to its permanence and storage of goods for business purposes. Consequently, the applicant is required to obtain GST registration in Odisha. The location of supply of services under Section 2(71) is the fixed establishment in Odisha, not the principal place of business in Maharashtra, as the supply is made from the Odisha location.

---

---

ISSUES:

Whether repair and maintenance services provided by the Head Office through Field Service Engineers (FSE) for Maintenance Contracts with customers in Odisha constitute a place of business in Odisha.Whether the temporary storage of spare parts and tool kits at the Applicant's location in Odisha constitutes a place of business.Whether the Applicant's location in Odisha qualifies as a "fixed establishment" under GST law.If the above are answered in the negative, whether the Applicant is required to take GST registration in Odisha.

RULINGS / HOLDINGS:

Repair and maintenance services provided through FSEs stationed in Odisha constitute a place of business in Odisha. "The Applicant satisfies the clause (a) & (c) of the definition of place of business."Temporary storage of spare parts and tool kits at the Applicant's location in Odisha constitutes a place of business. "The storage of spare parts and tool kit at Applicant's location would constitute a place of business under GST Act."The Applicant's location in Odisha qualifies as a "fixed establishment" because it has a sufficient degree of permanence and is suitably structured in terms of human and technical resources to supply services. "The applicant's establishment has sufficient degree of permanence" and "stores spare parts, tool kits in their location for supply of service."The Applicant is required to take GST registration in Odisha. "The location of Supply of Service as per Section 2(71) will be in the state of Odisha."

RATIONALE:

The Court applied the definitions and provisions under the CGST Act, 2017, particularly Sections 2(50) (fixed establishment), 2(71) (location of supplier of services), 2(85) (place of business), and Section 22 (persons liable for registration).The Court emphasized that a "fixed establishment" requires a "sufficient degree of permanence" and suitable human and technical resources, both of which were satisfied by the Applicant's operations in Odisha through stationed FSEs and storage of spare parts and tool kits.It was held that the presence of FSEs and temporary storage of goods, even if for operational efficiency and to reduce service delays, constitutes a place of business and fixed establishment under GST law.The Court distinguished the facts from prior rulings cited by the Applicant and relied on the principle that the location where services are effectively supplied and where human and technical resources are deployed for service delivery is the relevant place of business for GST registration.The Court referred to precedent from the Authority for Advance Ruling (Odisha) in a similar case, reinforcing the requirement of registration where fixed establishments exist for service supply.

---