Compensatory interest on motor accident compensation is not taxable income, and TDS on that component is unwarranted.

Interest on enhanced motor accident compensation awarded from the claim petition to the appellate judgment is treated as compensatory and forms part of the compensation, not as taxable income. Section 56(2)(viii) and Section 145B(1) determine when income is taxed if the receipt is otherwise income, but do not convert a non-income receipt into taxable income. Section 194A is only a TDS machinery provision and cannot decide taxability of the underlying receipt. On that basis, deduction of tax from the interest component was unwarranted and the deducted amount was directed to be released.

---

---

Issues: Whether interest on enhanced motor accident compensation awarded from the date of the claim petition till the appellate judgment is taxable and whether tax deducted at source from such interest was justified.

Analysis: The interest awarded under the Motor Vehicles Act is compensatory in nature and forms part of the compensation, being granted for delayed payment of the amount determined with reference to the date of accident. Section 56(2)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and Section 145B(1) only indicate the point of taxation if the receipt is otherwise income, but do not themselves make a non-income receipt taxable. Section 194A is only a machinery provision for deduction at source and cannot govern the taxability of the underlying receipt. On this understanding, interest on motor accident compensation from the date of the claim petition till the award or appellate judgment is not exigible to tax, and deduction of tax from that component is unwarranted.

Conclusion: The tax deducted from the interest component of the enhanced compensation was not justified, and the petitioner was entitled to release of the deducted amount.

Ratio Decidendi: Interest awarded on motor accident compensation for the period from the claim petition until the award or appellate judgment is compensatory and not taxable as income, and provisions governing receipt-based taxation or TDS do not convert such a non-taxable receipt into taxable income.

---