Freight & IT Support Expenses Disallowed: No Scientific Basis Found for Provisions Totaling Over Rs. 64 Lakh.

The ITAT Pune 'C' bench upheld the disallowance of provisions for Freight and Material Handling Charges amounting to Rs. 16,27,824/- and IT Support Expenses totaling Rs. 48,08,167/-. The assessee failed to establish a scientific basis for these provisions, as required for allowable expenditures, leading to the dismissal of Ground No. 9.

---

---

Issues:
1. Non-consideration of DRP's direction for granting relief in provision for expenses.

Analysis:

Provision for Freight and Material Handling Charges:
The ITAT Pune 'C' bench recalled an order to adjudicate Ground Number 9 raised by the assessee regarding the provision for expenses. The Assessing Officer proposed disallowance of Rs. 16,27,824/- as a provision made by the assessee towards Freight and material handling charges. The Dispute Resolution Panel directed the AO to examine the basis of the provision. The assessee claimed the provision was made on an accrual basis and adjusted against subsequent year's invoices. However, the AO disallowed the amount as the provision lacked scientific basis. The ITAT upheld the AO's decision as the assessee failed to provide evidence of a scientific basis for the provision, leading to the disallowance of Rs. 16,27,824/-.

IT Support Expenses:
The AO proposed disallowance of Rs. 48,08,167/- out of the total IT support expenses debited by the assessee. The DRP directed the assessee to prove the provision was made on a scientific basis, but the assessee failed to provide any supporting documents. The assessee admitted the provision was made on an estimated basis, and no scientific basis was established. The ITAT emphasized that provisions are not allowable expenditures unless made on a scientific basis. As the assessee could not prove the provision was made on a scientific basis, the ITAT dismissed Ground No. 9 raised by the assessee, resulting in the disallowance of Rs. 48,08,167/-.

In conclusion, the ITAT upheld the disallowance of both provisions for Freight and Material Handling Charges and IT Support Expenses, as the assessee failed to demonstrate a scientific basis for the provisions. The judgment highlights the importance of establishing a scientific basis for provisions to claim them as allowable expenditures.

---

---