Pre-deposit waiver in classification dispute upheld on strong prima facie case for body-built motor vehicle exemption.

In stay proceedings, the Tribunal considered whether pre-deposit of adjudged duty and penalty could be waived on the basis of a strong prima facie case arising from classification of body-built motor vehicles and the applicability of an exemption notification. It relied on a prior High Court ruling that such body building fell under the relevant tariff heading and could qualify for exemption, subject to the turnover condition. The Tribunal treated that ruling as sufficient prima facie support, rejected the objection based on its all-India jurisdiction, and dispensed with pre-deposit unconditionally while staying recovery during the appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether, in the stay proceedings, pre-deposit of the adjudged duty and penalty should be dispensed with on the basis of a strong prima facie case arising from the classification of body-built motor vehicles and the applicability of the exemption notification.

Analysis: The application was considered against a prior High Court decision holding that body building of motor vehicles falls under the relevant tariff heading and may qualify for exemption under the notification, subject to the turnover condition. The Tribunal treated that decision as furnishing a strong prima facie basis in favour of the applicants and rejected the objection that the High Court ruling lacked applicability in view of the Tribunal's all-India jurisdiction.

Conclusion: Pre-deposit of the duty and penalty was dispensed with unconditionally, and recovery of the adjudged amounts was stayed during the pendency of the appeal.

---