Weighted deduction under section 35B depends on direct export nexus; common overheads need reasonable apportionment.

Weighted deduction under section 35B is available for expenditure directly connected with export promotion, but not for outlays that form part of production or distribution costs. Current charges for running a freezing plant were treated as part of the cost of making goods marketable in India and were excluded, so no relief was allowed. Quality control inspection expenses and export credit guarantee commission were treated as eligible export incentive expenditure, so weighted deduction was allowed. Telephone, telex, salary and bonus expenses were treated as common overheads, requiring reasonable apportionment, and deduction was restricted to 50 per cent of those common expenses.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether weighted deduction under section 35B was admissible on current charges incurred for running the freezing plant. (ii) Whether weighted deduction was admissible on quality control inspection expenses and export credit guarantee commission. (iii) Whether weighted deduction on telephone, telex, salary and bonus expenses was to be allowed in full or only partly as common export-related expenditure.

Issue (i): Whether weighted deduction under section 35B was admissible on current charges incurred for running the freezing plant.

Analysis: The outlay on electricity/current charges was treated as expenditure forming part of the cost of making the goods marketable and as expenditure in India connected with distribution, supply or provision of goods, attracting the exclusion under section 35B(1)(b)(iii).

Conclusion: Weighted deduction on current charges was disallowed and the refusal of relief was upheld.

Issue (ii): Whether weighted deduction was admissible on quality control inspection expenses and export credit guarantee commission.

Analysis: These items were held to fall within the category of expenditure eligible for export incentive weightage, following the view already taken in the Full Bench decision referred to in the order.

Conclusion: Weighted deduction was allowed on both quality control inspection expenses and export credit guarantee commission.

Issue (iii): Whether weighted deduction on telephone, telex, salary and bonus expenses was to be allowed in full or only partly as common export-related expenditure.

Analysis: Telephone expenses, telex charges, salary and bonus were treated as common expenses, part of which related to purchases and processing rather than exclusively to export effort. The deductible portion was therefore restricted to a reasonable apportionment.

Conclusion: Weighted deduction was allowed only to the extent of 50 per cent of the common expenses, with relief on telex charges, resulting in a higher allowance than that granted by the assessing authority.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded only in part, with relief granted on some export-related items and partial allowance on common expenses, while the claim on current charges remained disallowed.

Ratio Decidendi: For weighted deduction under section 35B, expenditure directly referable to export promotion qualifies, but common overheads must be reasonably apportioned and expenditure forming part of the cost of production or distribution is excluded.

---