Wealth-tax land valuation reduced after considering location disadvantage, survey-number guidance, and later valuation date.

Valuation of 14 cents of vacant land in Coimbatore for wealth-tax purposes was examined against competing indicators, including a neighbouring acquisition, urban land tax valuation, a partition deed and the rise in land values over time. The land formed part of a larger survey number, the guideline value was considered relatable to the survey number as a whole, and the site had a slight disadvantage as a hind land on a private road. As the urban land tax valuation reflected values as on 1 June 1971 and the relevant valuation date was 31 March 1976, the earlier rate was not accepted in full and the value was revised downward to Rs. 2,500 per cent.

---

---

Issues: Whether the valuation of 14 cents of vacant site in Coimbatore for wealth-tax purposes should be sustained at Rs. 3,000 per cent or modified to a lower rate.

Analysis: The assessee relied on the valuation adopted in respect of a neighbouring acquisition and on the urban land tax valuation, while the Revenue relied on the partition deed valuation and the rise in land values over time. The site formed part of a larger survey number, the guideline value was generally relatable to the survey number as a whole, and the land had a slight disadvantage as it was in a hind land on a private road. The valuation made by the urban land tax authorities was also based on prevailing values as on 1 June 1971, whereas the relevant valuation date was 31 March 1976. Having regard to these circumstances, a revised valuation was considered .

Conclusion: The valuation was reduced to Rs. 2,500 per cent, which is partly in favour of the assessee.

---