Agency payment and commodity conversion: sleeper supplies escaped local tax, but converted timber turnover addition was sustained.

Documentary evidence showed that the sleeper supplies were contracted to the Railway Sleeper Controller, with the Divisional Forest Officer making payment only as agent. On that basis, the supplies were not local sales in Orissa and the turnover addition of Rs. 75,083-24 was directed to be deleted. By contrast, round logs purchased and then converted into sized timber were treated as a different commercial commodity, and the resulting sales justified an addition to turnover for violation of the relevant Central Sales Tax provision. The matter therefore distinguishes inter-State contractual supplies from transactions involving conversion into a new commodity, with relief limited to the sleeper-supply turnover.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the sleeper supplies were sales in Orissa liable to tax under the Orissa Sales Tax Act, or were inter-State transactions with the Railway Sleeper Controller acting through the Divisional Forest Officer as agent for payment. (ii) Whether purchase of round logs, conversion into sized timber, and their sale attracted addition to turnover for violation of Section 5(2)(A)(a)(ii) of the Central Sales Tax Act.

Issue (i): Whether the sleeper supplies were sales in Orissa liable to tax under the Orissa Sales Tax Act, or were inter-State transactions with the Railway Sleeper Controller acting through the Divisional Forest Officer as agent for payment.

Analysis: The booking instructions, contract, passing list, advance vouchers, final bill, railway invoice, and reminder all indicated that the assessee was the consignor and the Sleeper Controller was the consignee. The divisional forest officer merely made payment on behalf of the Sleeper Controller. The transaction therefore arose under the contract with the Sleeper Controller and not as a local sale to the forest officers in Orissa.

Conclusion: The sleeper sales were not taxable as local sales in Orissa, and the addition of Rs. 75,083-24 to turnover was liable to be deleted.

Issue (ii): Whether purchase of round logs, conversion into sized timber, and their sale attracted addition to turnover for violation of Section 5(2)(A)(a)(ii) of the Central Sales Tax Act.

Analysis: Once round logs were purchased and thereafter sold after conversion into sized timber, the goods had become a different commercial commodity. The assessee had effected transactions of conversion and sale in a manner that constituted a violation attracting the turnover addition.

Conclusion: The addition on this account was rightly made and was sustained.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded only in relation to the sleeper-supply turnover, while the turnover addition relating to conversion of logs into sized timber was maintained.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the documentary evidence shows that payment by a local officer was made only as agent on behalf of an out-of-State purchaser, the sale is not a local sale in Orissa; however, conversion of purchased logs into a different commercial commodity can justify an addition to turnover for statutory violation.

---