Rule 57CC reversal: no penalty or interest where there was no suppression and credit was already reversed.

Amounts reversed under Rule 57CC were treated as already paid, and prior precedent had held that such sums were not recoverable as duty under Section 11A or Rule 57I(1). Although Clause 82 of the Finance Act, 2005 retrospectively enabled recovery, the Explanation preserved the principle that conduct not punishable earlier could not be treated as an offence for penalty purposes. In the absence of fraud, wilful misstatement, collusion, suppression of facts, or intent to evade duty, and where the assessee had already reversed the credit, penalty and interest were held to be unsustainable and were set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether penalty and interest were leviable on the assessee in respect of the amount reversed under Rule 57CC, having regard to the absence of suppression of facts and the retrospective amendment introduced by Clause 82 of the Finance Act, 2005.

Analysis: The amount required to be reversed under Rule 57CC had already been paid by the assessee, and the Tribunal noted that the earlier position, as recognised in precedent, was that such amount was not recoverable as duty under Section 11A or under Rule 57I(1). The subsequent retrospective amendment under Clause 82 of the Finance Act, 2005 enabled recovery of the amount, but the Explanation preserved the principle that an omission which was not punishable earlier could not be treated as an offence for the purpose of penalty. The record disclosed no fraud, wilful misstatement, collusion, suppression of facts, or intent to evade duty. The assessee was also a PSU and had already reversed the credit amount, leaving no basis to sustain penal consequences or interest.

Conclusion: Penalty and interest were not leviable and were set aside.

---