Clubbing of clearances sustained where family-controlled units used common premises and facilities to wrongly claim exemption

Clearances of family-run units may be clubbed where the units have no real independent existence and operate from a common premises with shared facilities and office. Separate registrations, sales tax numbers and firm registration do not by themselves establish independence when surrounding facts show a common manufacturing concern created to wrongly claim the small-scale exemption. On the facts recorded at the spot, the clubbing of clearances was sustained, and the seized goods were liable to confiscation. Duty demand and penalties were also upheld, while the cited authorities were found inapplicable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the clearances of the three units were liable to be clubbed and the goods seized and penal action sustained on the ground that the units were not independent and had wrongly availed the small-scale exemption.

Analysis: The units were found to be run by members of the same family, manufacturing the same goods from a common premises with common facilities and office. The record showed that the units lacked real independent existence, that the arrangement was adopted to avail the benefit of Notification No. 1/93-C.E. unlawfully, and that the plea of separate registration, separate sales tax numbers and registration with the Registrar of Firms did not establish genuine independence. The statements recorded at the spot, read with the surrounding facts, supported the conclusion that the clearances were rightly clubbed and the seized goods were liable to confiscation. The cited decisions were held to be inapplicable on the facts.

Conclusion: The clubbing of clearances, confiscation of goods, duty demand and penalties were upheld against the appellants.

Ratio Decidendi: Separate registrations and nominal formalities do not prevent clubbing of clearances where different units are one family-controlled manufacturing concern using common facilities to evade duty and wrongly claim exemption.

---