Minor admitted only to partnership benefits: deed valid for registration where no unlawful partner liability is imposed.

A partnership deed must be read as a whole to determine whether a minor is admitted only to the benefits of partnership or is wrongly treated as a full partner. Where the controlling recital shows that only the major members constituted the firm and the minor was admitted to benefits, ancillary clauses on capital, duration, or accounts do not by themselves convert the minor into a full partner. A minor cannot be made liable for losses, but a guardian may accept lawful incidental terms needed to secure the minor's benefits. On that construction, the firm remains entitled to registration under income-tax law.

---

---

Issues: Whether the partnership deed, on a reasonable construction, merely admitted the minors to the benefits of the partnership or made them full partners, and whether the firm was therefore entitled to registration under the income-tax law.

Analysis: The deed had to be construed as a whole and in a reasonable manner. The controlling recital expressly stated that the major members had constituted the partnership and admitted the minors only to the benefits of that partnership. Clauses relating to capital contribution, duration, and maintenance of accounts did not necessarily convert the minors into full partners. Under the Partnership Act, a minor cannot be made liable for losses, may be admitted only to the benefits of partnership, and may on attaining majority elect to continue or sever his connection with the firm. A guardian may accept benefits of partnership on behalf of a minor and agree to incidental terms necessary to effectuate that benefit, so long as the deed does not treat the minor as a full partner or impose unlawful liability on him.

Conclusion: The deed did not make the minors full partners; it only conferred the benefits of partnership on them. The firm was entitled to registration, and the objection to registration failed in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: A partnership deed is valid for registration purposes if, on a fair construction, it admits a minor only to the benefits of partnership and does not make the minor a full partner or impose on the minor liabilities prohibited by partnership law; a guardian may agree to lawful ancillary terms necessary to secure those benefits.

---