Charitable accumulation under section 11(2) survives a later board resolution when disclosure and filing requirements are substantially met.

Accumulation under section 11(2) was allowed where the assessee disclosed the intended charitable accumulation in the return, audit report and balance sheet, and filed Form 10 with the return. The Tribunal treated the later-dated Board resolution as a matter of form, not a statutory disqualification, because the record already showed the accumulation and charitable purpose were properly disclosed and no contrary material showed non-compliance with section 11(2) read with rule 17(2). The Revenue could not the claim merely because the formal resolution post-dated the return, and the benefit of accumulation was held allowable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee was entitled to accumulation under section 11(2) despite the Board resolution being dated after the return of income, and whether filing of Form 10 along with the return satisfied the statutory conditions.

Analysis: The assessee had declared the accumulation in the return and the relevant audit report and balance sheet reflected the accumulation for the stated charitable purpose. The timing of the Board resolution, by itself, was treated as a matter of form and not as a statutory disqualification, since the record showed that the accumulation was already disclosed in the accounts and the purpose was consistent with the assessee's earlier year accumulation. The statutory scheme was applied by examining the due filing of the return and the statement of accumulation, and no contrary material was found to show that the claim failed the requirements of section 11(2) read with rule 17(2). The Tribunal also found that the Revenue could not reject the claim merely on the premise that the resolution post-dated the return when the substantive disclosures were otherwise in place.

Conclusion: The denial of accumulation was unsustainable, and the assessee was held entitled to the benefit claimed under section 11(2).

Ratio Decidendi: A claim for accumulation under section 11(2) cannot be disallowed merely because the formal resolution is dated after the return, where the accumulation and charitable purpose are otherwise duly disclosed and the statutory filing requirements are substantially complied with.

---