Reasonable apprehension standard governs criminal trial transfers; subjective fear alone cannot justify shifting the proceedings.

A criminal trial may be transferred under Section 406 CrPC only where the applicant shows a reasonable, objective apprehension that a fair and impartial trial cannot be secured and that transfer is necessary for the ends of justice. Mere allegation or subjective fear is insufficient. On the materials placed, the Court found the trial court competent to conduct a fair trial and held that the apprehension of injustice was not reasonable; transfer would also prejudice the prosecution, the accused and the witnesses. The petition for transfer was therefore rejected and the trial directed to continue before the existing court.

---

---

Issues: Whether the transfer petitions seeking transfer of the criminal trial under Section 406 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 were maintainable on the ground of a reasonable apprehension that a fair and impartial trial would not be possible in the State of Punjab.

Analysis: Transfer of a criminal case is warranted only when the apprehension of injustice is reasonable and not based on conjecture or mere allegation. The governing test is whether, on the totality of circumstances, public confidence in the fairness of the trial would be seriously undermined and whether transfer is necessary for the ends of justice. On the materials placed, the Court found that the trial court was competent to conduct a fair trial, that the apprehension expressed was not reasonable, and that transfer at that stage would also prejudice the prosecution, the accused, and the witnesses.

Conclusion: The request for transfer was rejected; the petitioners failed to establish a reasonable apprehension of denial of justice.

Final Conclusion: The criminal trial was directed to continue before the existing trial court, as no ground was made out for transfer in exercise of the Supreme Court's power under Section 406.

Ratio Decidendi: A criminal case may be transferred only when the party seeking transfer shows a reasonable, objective apprehension of denial of a fair trial; a mere allegation or subjective fear is insufficient.

---