Pre-deposit in excise classification dispute upheld where domestic electric flour mills were prima facie classifiable as electro-mechanical appliances.

In a central excise classification dispute over domestic electric flour mills, the Tribunal's partial pre-deposit order was upheld because the goods were, prima facie, classifiable under heading 8509 as electro-mechanical domestic appliances rather than under heading 8437 as claimed. The Tribunal had considered financial hardship and only the limited merits necessary for waiver, and the record did not show a clear prima facie case for unconditional waiver. The challenge to the pre-deposit direction therefore failed, and no interference was warranted.

---

---

Issues: Whether interference was warranted with the Tribunal's order directing partial pre-deposit in a central excise dispute concerning the classification of domestic electric flour mills and the claimed exemption.

Analysis: The Tribunal had considered financial hardship and, at the same time, examined the merits only to the limited extent necessary for deciding waiver. The dispute turned on whether the goods, being domestic flour mills fitted with an electric motor, were classifiable under heading 8509 as electro-mechanical domestic appliances or under heading 8437 as claimed by the petitioners. The Court accepted the Tribunal's view that, prima facie, such goods fell under heading 8509 and not heading 8437. On that basis, and in view of the record considered by the Tribunal, the petitioners had not established a clear prima facie case for unconditional waiver.

Conclusion: The challenge to the Tribunal's pre-deposit order failed and no interference was called for.

---