Common parlance test for tariff classification: toy fans not treated as electric fans, so excise demand and confiscation failed.

Where a tariff entry does not define a commodity, classification must follow its ordinary and commonly understood meaning. Applying that test, toy or baby fans with negligible air displacement and no real ability to function as fans were held not to be "electric fans" under the tariff item. Their outward appearance was insufficient; the decisive factor was whether they could in fact perform the essential function of a fan. The excise classification was therefore erroneous, and the duty demand, penalty, and confiscation order were unsustainable. The confiscated goods were ordered to be returned, with refund of any duty or penalty paid.

---

---

Issues: Whether the toy or baby fans manufactured by the petitioners were "electric fans" within Tariff Item No. 33 so as to attract excise duty, penalty, and confiscation.

Analysis: The expression "electric fan" was not defined in the tariff, so the article had to be identified by its ordinary and commonly understood meaning. On the facts found, the article was only a curiosity or toy for children, with negligible air displacement and no real capability of functioning as a fan. The decisive test was not its outward appearance but whether it could in fact be used as a fan. Since it could not, it did not answer the description of an electric fan under the tariff entry.

Conclusion: The classification adopted by the Central Excise authorities was erroneous, and the levy of duty, penalty, and confiscation order were not sustainable. The finding is in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The impugned excise demands and penal consequences were set aside, and the confiscated article was directed to be returned with refund of any duty or penalty paid.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a tariff entry does not define a commodity, the article must be classified according to its ordinary/common parlance meaning, and a mere toy or curiosity not capable of performing the essential function of the named goods does not fall within that entry.

---