Capital sentencing principles: death penalty reserved for rarest cases, with life imprisonment and remission requiring principled, case-by-case assessment.

Capital sentencing must reserve death for the rarest of rare cases where life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed. Aggravating factors relate to the crime and mitigating factors to the criminal, so they cannot be mechanically weighed on a balance sheet. Sentencing must be principled rather than judge-centric, and standardisation of crimes has limited value. Remission is a statutory process subject to procedural and substantive safeguards, requiring case-by-case consideration with judicial input, and life imprisonment cannot be treated as a fixed notional term for remission purposes. Applying these principles, the death penalty was not sustained and was converted into imprisonment for life.

---

---

Issues: Whether the death sentence awarded for murder deserved to be upheld, and whether the sentencing framework required a fresh approach to aggravating and mitigating circumstances, the role of the criminal, and remission in life imprisonment cases.

Analysis: The sentence for murder must ordinarily follow life imprisonment, with death reserved for the rarest of rare cases where life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed. The decision emphasises that aggravating circumstances relate to the crime, mitigating circumstances relate to the criminal, and that both cannot be mechanically placed on a balance sheet as if they were comparable. It further stresses that sentencing must be principled rather than judge-centric, that standardization of crimes has limited value, and that remission is statutory and subject to procedural and substantive safeguards, including case-by-case consideration and the presiding judge's opinion under the governing procedure. Life imprisonment is not to be treated as a notional fixed term for remission purposes.

Conclusion: The death penalty could not be sustained and was converted into imprisonment for life.

Ratio Decidendi: In capital sentencing, death can be imposed only when life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed, and remission or life imprisonment cannot be reduced to an arbitrary fixed-term construct; the statutory remission process must be applied case by case with judicial input.

---