Freight Forwarder Not Liable for Service Tax on Cargo Space Mark-Up, Tribunal Rules in Favor of Appellant

The Tribunal held that the appellant, a freight forwarder, was not liable to pay service tax on the mark-up earned from selling cargo space to exporters. The Tribunal determined that the mark-up resulted from a business transaction rather than a taxable service, as the appellant purchased space from shipping lines and sold it at a profit. Consequently, the orders by the Commissioner (Appeals) were set aside, and the appeals were allowed, aligning with previous Tribunal decisions supporting the appellant's position.

---

---

Issues Involved:
The judgment involves the demand of service tax on the mark-up earned by a freight forwarder over the freight amount from the sale of cargo space to exporters.

Issue 1 - Demand of Service Tax on Mark-up Earned:
The appellant, a freight forwarder, booked space for export containers with shipping companies and sold this space to exporters at a mutually decided ocean freight rate, which included a mark-up. The department proposed a levy of service tax on this mark-up, which was confirmed. The appellant argued that previous Tribunal decisions, such as Tiger Logistics (India) Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Service Tax, II, Delhi, supported their position that no service tax should be levied on such mark-ups.

Issue 2 - Tribunal's Decision and Analysis:
The Tribunal considered the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994, and emphasized that if a service is not rendered or does not fall within the definition of a taxable service, no service tax can be levied. The Tribunal highlighted that any amount received must be for the service provided and not for any other purpose. In the case of the appellant, the Tribunal found that the mark-up earned was a result of a business activity rather than a service provided, as the appellant bought space from shipping lines and sold it to customers at a profit margin. The Tribunal noted that the appellant took on the risk of being unable to sell the space at a profit, which indicated a business transaction rather than a service. Citing previous decisions, the Tribunal concluded that the appellant was not liable to pay service tax on the mark-up earned.

Decision:
Based on the Tribunal's analysis and previous decisions, it was held that the appellant was not liable to pay service tax as no service was provided. The orders passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) were set aside, and the appeals were allowed.

This summary provides a detailed breakdown of the issues involved in the judgment and the Tribunal's decision regarding the demand of service tax on mark-up earned by the freight forwarder.

---