Chartered Accountant certificate accepted for refund support where records showed no contrary material or breach of refund conditions.

A Chartered Accountant's certificate was treated as sufficient support for a refund claim of Special Additional Duty where the supporting accounting records were examined and no contrary material showed that earlier invoices or books were excluded or that the duty was not reflected in the accounts. A bare objection that the certificate covered only part of the relevant period was held inadequate in the absence of evidence discrediting the certificate or showing breach of the refund conditions. The refund sanction was therefore sustained and the departmental challenge failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Chartered Accountant's certificate was sufficient and valid to support sanction of refund of Special Additional Duty under the refund notification.

Analysis: The refund claim was examined with reference to the Chartered Accountant's certificate and the accounting records relied upon by the claimant. The objection that the certificate covered only part of the relevant period was not supported by any material showing that the earlier invoices or books of account were excluded or that the claimed duty was not reflected in the accounts. The Tribunal found that the Department had not produced evidence to discredit the certificate or to show that the refund conditions were violated.

Conclusion: The certificate was held to be sufficient for the refund claim, and the Department's challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The refund sanction was sustained and the departmental appeal did not succeed.

Ratio Decidendi: A refund claim cannot be denied merely on a speculative objection to the scope of a Chartered Accountant's certificate when the record does not show any contrary material or violation of the refund conditions.

---