Natural justice required remand where used electrical equipment was decided without full opportunity to file supporting valuation evidence.

Used electrical and electronic equipment imported under category (iii) could not be finally adjudicated without giving the importer a full opportunity to place supporting evidence, including the Chartered Engineer's certificate, before the adjudicating authority. Because that evidence had already been relied upon in de novo proceedings for other categories and was relevant to valuation, the matter required fresh consideration. The principles of natural justice therefore justified remand of category (iii) goods for re-adjudication.

---

---

Issues: Whether the order confirming confiscation and redemption fine in respect of the used electrical and electronic equipment/appliances category should be sustained or the matter should be remanded for fresh adjudication.

Analysis: The classification of the imported goods into different categories was accepted, but the used electrical and electronic equipment/appliances category was dealt with finally by the lower appellate authority without giving the appellant a full opportunity to place documentary evidence, including the Chartered Engineer's certificate, before the adjudicating authority. The record also showed that in the de novo proceedings for other categories, the certificate had been relied upon for valuation, indicating its relevance. In these circumstances, a fresh opportunity was required and the principles of natural justice had to be followed.

Conclusion: The issue is decided in favour of the appellant and the matter is remanded to the adjudicating authority for fresh consideration of category (iii) goods.

---