BIS registration for inflatable party items denied where toy-safety rules apply only to products intended for children under 14.

Inflatable party items were treated as outside the scope of the Toys (Quality Control) Order, 2020 because the applicable Indian Standard was understood to cover products designed or clearly intended for play by children under 14 years. The earlier departmental report was found inconclusive and unsupported by detailed analysis, while the Government of India clarification was treated as decisive on the reach of toy-safety requirements. On that basis, the imported items were not required to obtain BIS registration, and the Revenue's challenge to the classification and consequential confiscation findings failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether inflatable party items were correctly held classifiable under Heading 9503 so as to attract BIS registration, or whether they were outside the scope of the Toys (Quality Control) Order, 2020 and therefore not liable to such registration.

Analysis: The earlier departmental report was found to be inconclusive and unsupported by detailed analysis. The Government of India clarification was treated as decisive, indicating that the relevant Indian Standard on toy safety and toy balloons applies to products designed or clearly intended for use in play by children under 14 years of age. On that basis, the imported inflatable party items were held to be outside the scope of BIS registration under the Toys (Quality Control) Order, 2020, and the NCTC report relied on by the Revenue was found to have no basis.

Conclusion: The items were not required to obtain BIS registration, and the Revenue's challenge to the classification and consequential confiscation findings failed.

---