Motor accident compensation interest: pre-judgment TDS impermissible, while post-judgment interest remains taxable.

Interest awarded on motor accident compensation for the period up to the award or, in appeal, up to the High Court judgment is not taxable in the hands of the claimant, so tax deduction at source on that component was impermissible and had to be refunded. Section 194A of the Income-tax Act is only a deduction-at-source mechanism and cannot create taxability where the receipt is otherwise not income. Interest accruing after the High Court judgment was treated as taxable income from other sources, and deduction of tax on that post-judgment interest was permissible.

---

---

Issues: Whether tax deducted at source could be levied on interest awarded on motor accident compensation up to the date of the High Court judgment, and whether the insurer was bound to refund the amount so deducted.

Analysis: The Court followed the Division Bench ruling that interest awarded in motor accident claim cases from the date of the claim petition till the award, or in appeal till the High Court judgment, is not exigible to tax because it is not income in the hands of the claimant. It further held that Section 194A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is only a provision for deduction at source and does not determine the taxability of the receipt. On that basis, deduction of TDS on the interest component up to the date of the High Court judgment was held to be impermissible, while interest accruing after that date could be subjected to tax deduction as income from other sources.

Conclusion: The TDS deducted on the interest component up to the date of the High Court judgment had to be refunded, and the deduction of TDS on post-judgment interest was held permissible.

Final Conclusion: The petition succeeded to the extent of directing refund of TDS deducted on pre-judgment interest in the motor accident compensation, while preserving the right to deduct tax on interest accruing after the High Court judgment.

Ratio Decidendi: Interest awarded on motor accident compensation for the period up to the award or appellate judgment is not taxable in the hands of the claimant, and a provision for tax deduction at source cannot create taxability where none otherwise exists.

---