Prior secured creditor interest prevails over later customs dues absent a statutory first charge, under SARFAESI priority principles.

A prior mortgage and auction sale certificate in favour of a secured creditor prevailed over the customs department's later claim and communication, because no specific statutory first charge under customs law was shown. Applying the overriding effect of the SARFAESI Act, including Section 26E, the Court held that an earlier created security interest ranks ahead of subsequent customs dues and attachment claims unless the other enactment expressly creates a first charge. The customs attachment was therefore liable to be lifted, and the bank's secured interest was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the secured creditor's mortgage and auction sale certificate had priority over the customs department's later claim and communication, and whether the customs attachment was liable to be lifted.

Analysis: The property had been mortgaged in favour of the bank before the customs department issued its notices and communication. The Court noted that the customs department had not created any statutory first charge over the property and had only sent a communication requesting that transfers not be entertained. Section 26E of the SARFAESI Act, together with the overriding effect of that enactment, was applied to hold that a secured creditor's interest prevails over subsequent claims, unless the other enactment contains a specific first-charge provision. The Court also relied on the principle that customs dues, in the absence of a specific statutory first charge, do not override a valid security interest created earlier in time.

Conclusion: The bank's secured interest prevailed over the customs claim, and the direction to lift the attachment over the property was upheld. The writ appeal failed.

Ratio Decidendi: In the absence of a specific statutory first-charge provision in the customs law, a prior security interest created in favour of a secured creditor prevails over subsequent customs dues and related attachment claims by virtue of the overriding effect of the SARFAESI Act.

---