Broad taxing entry for iron and steel goods covers fabricated frames and grills unless a more specific entry applies.

Entry 43 of the notification was construed to cover mill stores and hardware, including iron and steel goods not covered by any other item in the Schedule or any other notification, except iron or steel wires. Applying that broad wording, the Court held that fabricated iron frames, grills and similar iron and steel goods fell within the entry because they answered the generic description of iron and steel goods, even if they had a more specific commercial identity. Earlier decisions were distinguished as the amended entry was materially different. As no more specific entry was shown, the goods were not taxable as unclassified commodities at 10%.

---

---

Issues: Whether iron frames, grills, and similar fabricated iron and steel goods were covered by Entry 43 of Notification No. KA. NI. -2-100/XI-9(231)/94-U.P. Act-15-48-Order-2000 dated 15 January, 2000, so as to attract tax at 10% as unclassified goods.

Analysis: Entry 43 described mill stores and hardware and also extended to iron and steel goods not covered by any other item of the Schedule or any notification issued under the Act, while specifically excluding iron or steel wires. The broader words used in the entry were held to include commodities that answer the generic description of iron and steel goods, even if they have a more specific commercial identity. The reasoning of earlier decisions was found inapplicable because the amended entry was materially different. Since no more appropriate specific entry was shown for the goods in question, the taxing entry was construed to cover them.

Conclusion: The goods were covered by Entry 43 and could not be taxed as unclassified commodities at 10%.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a taxing entry expressly includes iron and steel goods not covered elsewhere, fabricated goods of iron and steel fall within it unless specifically excluded or shown to be covered by a more appropriate specific entry.

---