Trade classification of starter armatures favours motor vehicle parts over electric motor parts under excise law.

Starter armatures were treated as motor vehicle parts because excise classification depends on how goods are understood in trade and commerce, not on technical or dictionary meaning. The Department had to show that they were more appropriately classifiable as parts of electric motors, but the trade evidence indicated that starter armatures are obtained from the automobile spare parts market and are used only in automobile starters. Item 34A, covering parts and accessories of motor vehicles not otherwise specified, therefore applied, and the fact that an armature performs a function connected with an electric motor did not alter its commercial identity as a motor vehicle part.

---

---

Issues: Whether starter armatures are classifiable as parts of motor vehicles under Item 34A of the First Schedule to the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944, or as parts of electric motors under Item 30(4) of the First Schedule to the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944.

Analysis: Classification of excisable goods must be determined in the sense in which the goods are understood in trade and commerce, and not by technical or dictionary meaning. The Department bore the burden of showing that starter armatures, which are commercially known and dealt with as automobile ancillary parts, were more appropriately covered as parts of electric motors. The evidence from trade associations supported the view that these armatures are obtained from the automobile spare parts market and are meant for use only in automobile starters. Item 34A covered parts and accessories of motor vehicles not otherwise specified, and the mere fact that an armature performs a function connected with an electric motor did not take it out of the commercial identity of a motor vehicle part. The residuary approach also supported classification under the motor vehicle entry rather than under Item 30(4).

Conclusion: Starter armatures are classifiable as parts of motor vehicles under Item 34A of the First Schedule to the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944, and not as parts of electric motors under Item 30(4).

---