Article 20(3) and Customs proceedings: adjudication may continue despite parallel criminal case, with self-incrimination safeguards remaining limited.

Departmental proceedings under the Customs Act are treated as adjudicatory, not criminal, so Article 20(3) is not attracted merely because a noticee must place a defence before customs authorities. The text states that issuance of a show-cause notice does not amount to testimonial compulsion, and voluntary evidence given by a person examined as a witness does not by itself create self-incrimination. It also notes that compelled answers are separately protected by Section 132 of the Evidence Act, including against use in later criminal proceedings. On that basis, the customs authorities' refusal to stay the proceedings was upheld and the departmental process was allowed to continue.

---

---

Issues: Whether departmental proceedings under the Customs Act were required to be stayed pending the criminal case on the ground of Article 20(3) of the Constitution and possible self-incrimination, and whether the summons of a petitioner as a witness warranted interference.

Analysis: Proceedings under the Customs Act are not criminal proceedings, and the mere issuance of a show-cause notice does not amount to testimonial compulsion. The protection under Article 20(3) is not attracted at the stage of adjudication merely because the petitioners may have to place their defence before the customs authorities. Even if a person is examined as a witness in such proceedings, voluntary evidence given in defence does not by itself constitute compulsion within Article 20(3). As to compelled answers, Section 132 of the Indian Evidence Act affords protection, and the proviso prevents compelled answers from being used in subsequent criminal proceedings. The Customs Authorities were also found to have exercised their discretion properly in declining to stay the proceedings.

Conclusion: The request for stay was rejected, and the departmental proceedings under the Customs Act were permitted to continue.

---