Approved despatch documents and no mala fide conduct justified deletion of penalty, with fine substantially reduced.

Penalty was not warranted where consignments moved under approved despatch advices-cum-invoices, sufficient PLA balance was available, and no mala fide conduct was shown, so the penalty was deleted. The omission to make debit entries in the PLA nevertheless left the action in rem legally sustainable, but the surrounding circumstances justified substantial reduction of the fine imposed on the offending goods. The revision therefore succeeded only in deleting the penalty and reducing the fine, while the remainder of the order was maintained.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether penalty could be sustained where the consignments were covered by approved despatch advices-cum-invoices, sufficient PLA balance existed, and no mala fide was found; (ii) whether the fine imposed in respect of the offending goods required interference in the circumstances of the case.

Issue (i): whether penalty could be sustained where the consignments were covered by approved despatch advices-cum-invoices, sufficient PLA balance existed, and no mala fide was found.

Analysis: The movement of iron and steel products and pig iron in respect of the consignments was covered by despatch advices-cum-invoices approved for use in lieu of gate passes, and there was sufficient balance in the PLA to meet the duty. Although debit entries in the PLA were not made, the record did not disclose mala fide conduct.

Conclusion: The penalty was not warranted and was set aside.

Issue (ii): whether the fine imposed in respect of the offending goods required interference in the circumstances of the case.

Analysis: The omission to make debit entries rendered the action in rem legally sustainable, but the surrounding circumstances justified reduction of the monetary burden attached to the offending goods.

Conclusion: The fine was reduced substantially.

Final Conclusion: The revision succeeded only to the extent of deleting the penalty and reducing the fine, while the remainder of the order was maintained.

---