Tractor tyre relugging treated as retreading, bringing the product within the relevant excise tariff entry.

Relugging of tractor tyres, involving the placement and curing of lugs over the tyre surface, is treated as a process akin to retreading. Because the lug forms part of the tread in a tractor tyre, the resulting product falls within the relevant excise tariff entry for such tyres. The operative effect is that the relugged tyre is assessable under Central Excise Tariff Item 16A(2), and the classification turns on the substantial similarity between relugging and retreading.

---

---

Issues: Whether relugging of tractor tyres amounts to a process akin to retreading and whether the resulting product is assessable under Central Excise Tariff Item 16A(2).

Analysis: Relugging was treated as the process of putting lugs all over the surface of a tractor tyre and curing them. The process was held to be akin to retreading in the case of any other tyre, and in a tractor tyre the lug forms part of the tread. On that basis, the product was considered to fall within the relevant excise tariff classification.

Conclusion: The product was held assessable under Central Excise Tariff Item 16A(2), and the revision was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the manufacturing process on a tractor tyre is substantially akin to retreading, the resulting product is classifiable for excise purposes under the tariff entry covering such tyres.

---