Electrical stampings classification denied for mild steel end plates used only for mechanical protection in stators and rotors.

Mild steel end plates used in stators and rotors for mechanical protection were held not to be electrical stampings under Tariff Item 28A of the Central Excise Tariff. They were made of M.S. sheets, used only to protect and hold the stator and rotor components, and did not perform any electrical function, act as laminations, or form part of the magnetic circuit. Because they were distinct from silicon steel stampings meant for electrical equipment, the disputed classification was rejected. The revision application succeeded, and the duty demand based on that classification could not stand.

---

---

Issues: Whether the end plates made of mild steel sheets, used in stators and rotors for mechanical protection, were classifiable as electrical stampings under Tariff Item 28A of the Central Excise Tariff.

Analysis: The end plates were found to be made of M.S. sheets and used only to protect and hold the stator and rotor components. They did not perform any electrical function as laminations or electrical stampings and did not form part of the magnetic circuit. The nature of the material and its use showed that the goods were distinct from silicon steel stampings meant for electrical equipment.

Conclusion: The end plates were not classifiable as electrical stampings under Tariff Item 28A and the petitioners were entitled to relief.

Final Conclusion: The revision application succeeded and the duty demand based on the disputed classification could not stand.

---