Appeal partly allowed, Revenue's appeal dismissed. Tribunal directs reconsideration of comparables. Order pronounced April 26, 2021.

The assessee's appeal was partly allowed for statistical purposes, and the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. The Tribunal directed the TPO/AO to reconsider certain comparables and verify specific details for proper adjudication. The order was pronounced on April 26, 2021.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Misconstruction of functional and risk profile by CIT(A).
2. Erroneous exclusion and inclusion of comparables by TPO and CIT(A).
3. Rejection of R Systems International Limited as a comparable.
4. Inclusion of TCS E-Serve International Limited and TCS E-Serve Limited as comparables.
5. Treatment of gain/loss from foreign exchange variation and provision for doubtful debts.
6. Non-granting of appropriate risk adjustments under Rule 10B.
7. Treatment of third-party cost recoveries for applying the mark-up.
8. Treatment of outstanding receivables from AE as an unsecured loan and charging interest thereon.
9. Exclusion of certain companies from the comparables list by CIT(A) in Revenue's appeal.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Misconstruction of Functional and Risk Profile:
The assessee argued that CIT(A) misconstrued its functional and risk profile. This ground was not pressed during the hearing and thus dismissed.

2. Erroneous Exclusion and Inclusion of Comparables:
- Microgenetics Systems Ltd.: The TPO excluded this comparable based on a turnover filter of Rs. 5 crores. The Tribunal directed the TPO/AO to reconsider this comparable after applying all filters and functional profiles.
- R Systems International Ltd.: The Tribunal found that audited financial data for the relevant year was available. The TPO/AO was directed to include this comparable after proper evaluation.
- TCS E-Serve International Ltd. and TCS E-Serve Ltd.: These were excluded as their functional profiles were different from the assessee's, involving software development activities without segmental details for ITeS/BPO activities.

3. Rejection of R Systems International Limited:
The Tribunal directed the TPO/AO to consider R Systems International Ltd. as a comparable, given the availability of relevant financial data.

4. Inclusion of TCS E-Serve International Limited and TCS E-Serve Limited:
These companies were excluded from the list of comparables due to their different functional profiles and lack of segmental data.

5. Treatment of Gain/Loss from Foreign Exchange Variation and Provision for Doubtful Debts:
The Tribunal upheld the TPO's approach of treating these as non-operating in nature, aligning with provisions in Rule 10TA and supporting case law.

6. Non-Granting of Appropriate Risk Adjustments:
The CIT(A) denied risk adjustments, and this decision was upheld by the Tribunal.

7. Treatment of Third-Party Cost Recoveries for Applying the Mark-Up:
The Tribunal agreed with CIT(A) that third-party expenses (travel, boarding, lodging) should have been marked up before recovery. The assessee's reliance on the Cheil Communication India Pvt. Ltd. case was found to be on a different factual footing.

8. Treatment of Outstanding Receivables from AE as an Unsecured Loan:
The Tribunal remanded the issue back to the TPO/AO for proper adjudication, emphasizing the need to verify the actual delay in invoice collection and apply the correct interest rate.

9. Exclusion of Certain Companies from Comparables List in Revenue's Appeal:
- Accentia Technology Pvt. Ltd.: Excluded due to an extraordinary event of merger.
- Eclerx Services Ltd.: Excluded due to different functional profiles.
- I Gate Global Services: Excluded due to lack of segmental data.
- Infosys BPO Ltd.: Excluded as it is a giant in software development, assumes higher risks, and had extraordinary economic events.

Conclusion:
The assessee's appeal was partly allowed for statistical purposes, and the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. The Tribunal directed the TPO/AO to reconsider certain comparables and verify specific details for proper adjudication. The order was pronounced on April 26, 2021.

---