Bona fide shipping bill errors should not defeat MEIS benefits when documentary evidence and substantive eligibility exist.

A bona fide omission to mark the correct export intent in EDI shipping bills should not, by itself, defeat MEIS benefits where the exporter is otherwise substantively eligible and supporting documentary evidence exists. The text explains that Section 149 of the Customs Act, 1962 permits amendment of shipping documents on the basis of existing records and is to be applied in a liberal, facilitative manner rather than with a rigid limitation approach. Where exports were otherwise covered under the relevant public notices and the mistake was purely procedural, refusal to allow amendment and the resulting denial of incentive were unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the refusal to permit amendment of the shipping bills and consequential denial of MEIS benefit was justified where the exporter had inadvertently marked the wrong intent and the exports were otherwise eligible under the later public notices.

Analysis: The writ petition arose from rejection of a request to amend EDI shipping bills so as to reflect the declaration of intent necessary for MEIS benefits. The exports had been made to Sri Lanka after the scheme was extended to that market, and the record showed that the shipping documents and related evidence were otherwise available. Section 149 of the Customs Act, 1962 permits amendment of documents on the basis of existing documentary evidence and does not prescribe a rigid limitation period. The scheme provisions and public notices were meant to facilitate exports, and the omission to mark the correct option in the electronic shipping bills was treated as an inadvertent procedural error rather than a substantive disqualification.

Conclusion: The refusal to permit amendment and to grant the consequential export incentive was unsustainable. The impugned communication was set aside and the exporter was entitled to the relief sought.

Ratio Decidendi: A bona fide procedural omission in shipping bills, where the exporter is otherwise substantively eligible and supporting documentary evidence exists, should not defeat MEIS benefits, and Section 149 of the Customs Act, 1962 must be applied with a liberal and facilitative approach.

---