Appellant wins Cenvat credit appeal despite procedural lapse, emphasizing substantive compliance over formality.

The appellant was denied Cenvat credit due to the factory address not being reflected in the invoices. However, as the appellant had properly recorded the credit in their registers and the invoices were issued in the name of the head office, the court ruled in favor of the appellant. The denial of credit based on a procedural lapse was deemed unjust, and the appeal was allowed with consequential relief. The judgment emphasizes that substantive benefits should not be withheld from taxpayers for minor procedural errors when all essential requirements are fulfilled.

---

---

Issues: Denial of Cenvat credit due to factory address not reflected in invoices.

Analysis:
The judgment pertains to the denial of Cenvat credit amounting to Rs. 99,589/- to the appellant for the period from April 2010 to March 2015. The denial was based on the ground that the factory address was not reflected in the invoices, with only the head office address being shown. However, it was noted that the appellant had duly reflected the credit in their RG-23A Part-I and Part-II registers. The Member (Judicial) emphasized the principle that substantive benefits cannot be denied due to procedural lapses. Citing a precedent from the case of Commr. of C. Ex. & Service Tax, Raipur Vs. Dayalal Meghji And Company, the judgment highlighted that if invoices were issued in the name of the appellant's head office, the appellant would be entitled to take the credit based on those invoices.

The Member (Judicial) concluded that as the appellant's head office address was clearly indicated and orders might have been placed from the head office, there was no valid reason to deny the credit. Consequently, the impugned orders were set aside, and the appeal was allowed with consequential relief. The judgment underscores the importance of not depriving legitimate benefits to taxpayers based on minor procedural irregularities, especially when the essential requirements for availing such benefits are met.

---