Goods classification for street lighting poles rejected as transmission line material under the VAT schedule entry.

Galvanized poles used for street lighting were held not to fall within the entry for overhead transmission line material under the Value Added Tax Act, 2008. The court read the goods entry alongside the Electricity Supply Code, 2005 definition of transmission line, which is confined to electricity transmission infrastructure and related equipment. Because lighting poles are distinct products meant for illumination rather than transmission of electricity, the Tribunal's analogy with feeder pillars was rejected. The goods were therefore treated as unclassified items for taxation.

---

---

Issues: Whether galvanized poles used for lighting fall within the entry for overhead transmission line material under Schedule-2, Part-GA, Sr. No. 236 of the Value Added Tax Act, 2008, or are liable to be treated as unclassified items.

Analysis: The disputed goods were examined against the statutory entry for overhead transmission line material and the definition of transmission line in the Electricity Supply Code, 2005. That definition covers systems used for transmitting electricity from a generating station to another generating station or to a sub-station, together with related equipment. Galvanized poles used for street lighting were found to be a distinct product, meant for lighting purposes and not for transmission of electricity. The Tribunal's approach in equating them with feeder pillars was held to be unsustainable because feeder pillars are used for electricity transmission, whereas lighting poles are not.

Conclusion: Galvanized poles used for lighting do not fall within the entry for overhead transmission line material and are liable to be taxed as unclassified items.

Ratio Decidendi: A goods entry covering overhead transmission line material cannot be ended to articles used only for lighting when the statutory definition of transmission line is confined to electricity transmission infrastructure.

---