Appeal upheld due to lack of notice. Key issue: Does cutting tapes into Velcro constitute manufacturing?

The appeal was decided on its merits despite the department's failure to serve notice of hearing to the respondents. The dispute centered on whether the process of slitting and cutting imported tapes into Velcro constituted manufacturing, exempting them from Anti Dumping Duty. The burden of proof was on the investigating authority to establish distinctiveness between the goods. Legal principles were applied to determine the creation of a new product, emphasizing the need for evidence and probabilities to evaluate the manufacturing activity. The Commissioner (Appeals) found the Velcro product to be distinct, leading to the rejection of the Revenue's appeal.

---

---

Issues:
1. Non-service of notice of hearing to the respondents by the department.
2. Classification of imported goods and liability to pay Anti Dumping Duty.
3. Determination of whether the process undertaken by the importer amounts to manufacture.
4. Application of legal principles to ascertain if a new product has come into existence.
5. Evaluation of evidence and probabilities to determine the manufacturing activity.
6. Comparison of goods to establish distinctiveness for Anti Dumping Duty.

Issue 1: Non-service of notice of hearing to the respondents by the department

The appeal was filed by the Revenue against the order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals). The department was directed to serve the notice of hearing to the respondents, and failure to do so would have led to the dismissal of the appeal. Despite the absence of proof of serving the respondents, the appeal was decided on its merits.

Issue 2: Classification of imported goods and liability to pay Anti Dumping Duty

The dispute revolved around the classification of Narrow Woven Fastening Tape Hook and Loop imported by the respondents under Chapter 54. The goods were cleared on payment of customs duty, but no Anti Dumping Duty was paid. The question was whether the process of slitting and cutting the tapes into Velcro amounted to manufacturing, thereby exempting them from Anti Dumping Duty.

Issue 3: Determination of whether the process undertaken by the importer amounts to manufacture

The Revenue contended that the process of slitting and cutting did not constitute manufacturing, making the importer liable for Anti Dumping Duty. The Commissioner (Appeals) observed that the burden of proof lay with the investigating authority to establish any distinctiveness between the imported goods and the cleared goods. The legal position was considered, emphasizing that a commercially known different product coming into existence suffices to constitute manufacture.

Issue 4: Application of legal principles to ascertain if a new product has come into existence

Legal principles were applied to determine whether the process undertaken resulted in the creation of a new product with a distinct name, character, and use. The judgment referenced various cases to establish that even if the inputs and final product fell under the same tariff heading, a different identifiable commercially known product could still be deemed to have been manufactured.

Issue 5: Evaluation of evidence and probabilities to determine the manufacturing activity

The judgment emphasized the need for evidence and probabilities to be evaluated for both sides to prove their stance in determining the manufacturing activity. The standard of proof in such proceedings was highlighted as preponderance of probabilities, where the evidence presented by each side was assessed to ascertain the prevailing stance.

Issue 6: Comparison of goods to establish distinctiveness for Anti Dumping Duty

The Commissioner (Appeals) noted that the resultant product, Velcro, was known differently in the market than the imported tapes, indicating a manufacturing process. The Revenue failed to provide arguments to counter this finding, leading to the rejection of their appeal based on the established legal principles and lack of evidence to prove otherwise.

---