Appellate authority confirms tax rates for Non-Woven & Cotton Carry Bags under CTH 4202 2210 & CTH 4202 22 20.

The appellate authority upheld the original ruling, confirming the classification of Non-Woven Carry Bags under CTH 4202 2210 and Cotton Carry Bags under CTH 4202 22 20. The applicable tax rates were also upheld, with Non-Woven bags remaining taxable at 9% under CGST and SGST, and Cotton bags at 6% under CGST and SGST. The appeal challenging the original ruling's validity and correctness was dismissed.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Classification of Non-Woven Carry Bags/Shopping Bags.
2. Classification of Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags.
3. Applicable rate of tax for Non-Woven and Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags before and after 15.11.2017.
4. Validity and correctness of the original Advance Ruling.

Issue-Wise Detailed Analysis:

1. Classification of Non-Woven Carry Bags/Shopping Bags:
The original Advance Ruling Authority classified Non-Woven Carry Bags/Shopping Bags under CTH 4202 2210. This classification was based on the material and usage of the bags as shopping bags rather than packing bags. The decision was not contested in the appeal, and the classification remained unchallenged.

2. Classification of Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags:
The original authority classified Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags under CTH 4202 22 20. The appellant contested this classification, arguing that these bags should be classified under Tariff Item No. 6305 20 00 as sacks and bags used for packing goods. The appellant argued that Chapter 42 covers articles of leather or materials with leather characteristics, which does not include cotton. However, the appellate authority upheld the original classification, stating that Chapter 42 is not limited to leather articles and specifically includes shopping bags of cotton with outer surfaces of textile materials.

3. Applicable Rate of Tax for Non-Woven and Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags Before and After 15.11.2017:
The original ruling stated:
- Before 15.11.2017, both Non-Woven and Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags were taxable at 9% under CGST and SGST.
- From 15.11.2017 onwards, Cotton Carry Bags/Shopping Bags were taxable at 6% under CGST and SGST, while Non-Woven Carry Bags remained taxable at 9% under CGST and SGST.
The appellant did not contest the tax rates for Non-Woven Bags but argued that Cotton Bags should attract 5% GST based on their classification under Chapter 6305. The appellate authority, however, upheld the original tax rates based on the classification under Chapter 4202.

4. Validity and Correctness of the Original Advance Ruling:
The appellant argued that the original ruling lacked proper reasoning and was not supported by Chapter Notes or interpretative rules. They also cited a CBIC circular clarifying the classification of Polypropylene Bags and contended that Cotton Bags should be classified similarly. The appellate authority refuted these arguments, stating that the original ruling was well-reasoned and supported by HSN explanatory notes and relevant customs tariff provisions. The authority also noted that the CBIC circular related to Polypropylene Bags was not applicable to Cotton Bags.

Conclusion:
The appellate authority upheld the original ruling, confirming the classification of Non-Woven Carry Bags under CTH 4202 2210 and Cotton Carry Bags under CTH 4202 22 20. The applicable tax rates were also upheld, and the appeal was dismissed.

---