Conditional stay of demand granted where disputed TDS liability was protected by immediate payment and early hearing.

Conditional interim protection against recovery may be granted in a stay application where the demand is disputed in appeal and the Revenue's interest is secured by reasonable terms. The Tribunal considered the revised CBDT stay guidelines, the nature of the additions under sections 201(1) and 201(1A), amounts already recovered or deposited, and the absence of any cash flow statement showing hardship. It also noted that the underlying dispute concerned whether discounts to prepaid distributors fell within section 194H. Stay of demand was granted subject to payment of Rs. 60,00,000, with the appeals listed for early hearing and the stay operating for six months or until disposal of the appeals, whichever was earlier.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee was entitled to stay of the outstanding demand arising from additions under sections 201(1) and 201(1A) pending disposal of the appeals, and on what terms.

Analysis: The application was considered in the light of the revised CBDT guidelines on stay of demand, the nature of the additions, the amounts already recovered and deposited, and the absence of any cash flow statement demonstrating financial hardship. The material placed before the Tribunal also showed that the dispute was linked to whether the discount to prepaid distributors fell within the scope of section 194H. The Tribunal balanced the competing positions of the parties and found it appropriate to grant protection against recovery while securing the Revenue's interest through a substantial immediate payment and an early hearing.

Conclusion: Stay of demand was granted subject to payment of Rs. 60,00,000 within seven working days, and the appeals were fixed for early hearing; the stay was to operate for six months or till disposal of the appeals, whichever was earlier.

Final Conclusion: The assessee obtained conditional interim relief against recovery, with the appeals expedited and clubbed with connected matters.

Ratio Decidendi: In a stay application, interim protection may be granted where the demand merits preservation pending appeal, provided the assessee secures the Revenue's interest by complying with reasonable conditions and the matter is listed for early hearing.

---