Transitional input tax credit denied for computers and laptops treated as capital goods, not eligible inputs under GST transition rules.

Transitional input tax credit under Section 140(3) is confined to inputs held in stock that are also eligible for input tax credit under the existing law and the GST regime. Computers and laptops used by a service provider were treated as capital goods in the pre-GST records and remained capitalised in the books, so they did not qualify as inputs for transitional credit merely because they were lying in closing stock on the appointed day. VAT paid on those goods was therefore not eligible for carry forward under Section 140(3), and the appeal was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether computers and laptops used by a service provider for rendering output services qualify as inputs for the purpose of transitional input tax credit under Section 140(3), and whether VAT paid on such goods lying in closing stock on the appointed day is eligible for credit.

Analysis: The goods were treated as capital assets in the pre-GST period and continued to be capitalised in the books. Under the transitional scheme, credit under Section 140(3) is available only in respect of inputs held in stock and only if the registered person is otherwise eligible for input tax credit on such inputs under the GST regime. The definition of inputs excludes capital goods, and for the transitional chapter, capital goods retain the meaning assigned under the Kerala VAT law. Since computers and laptops used for rendering services fall within capital goods and not inputs, the condition in Section 140(3) was not satisfied. The proviso to Section 140(2) also supported the view that credit not admissible under the existing law cannot be carried forward.

Conclusion: The computers and laptops did not qualify as inputs for transitional credit, and VAT paid on them was not eligible for credit under Section 140(3).

Final Conclusion: The appeal was rejected because transitional credit was unavailable on the goods in question under the GST transition provisions.

Ratio Decidendi: Transitional credit under Section 140(3) is confined to inputs eligible for input tax credit under both the existing law and the GST law, and goods treated as capital goods are not brought within that clause merely because they are held in stock on the appointed day.

---