Commercial profits under section 23A require real commercial assessment; disallowed losses are not automatically distributable profit.

Commercial profits under section 23A of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922 must be determined on broad commercial principles, not by treating every assessment disallowance as real profit. Only additions that genuinely reflect suppressed income or inflated expenditure can be regarded as distributable commercial profits. A mere disallowance of a claimed loss does not, by itself, prove that the disallowed amount was available for distribution. Because the primary facts needed to decide whether the claimed losses were true commercial losses or profits were not fully found, the issue had to be reconsidered on a proper factual basis.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for the purpose of section 23A of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, a disallowance made in assessment proceedings automatically constitutes commercial profit, and what principle governs the determination of commercial profits for the purpose of distribution.

Analysis: Commercial profits for section 23A have to be determined on broad commercial principles and not by equating every addition or disallowance in assessment with real profit. Only those additions which truly represent suppression of income or inflation of expenditure can be treated as commercial profits. A mere disallowance of a claimed loss does not, by itself, establish that the amount so disallowed was available as distributable commercial profit. The primary facts necessary to decide whether the losses claimed were in truth commercial losses or profits were not adequately found, so the reference could not be answered on the existing record.

Conclusion: The disallowed loss was not held to be automatically taxable commercial profit for section 23A purposes; the matter required fresh factual determination by the Tribunal.

Final Conclusion: The governing principle is that section 23A requires an assessment of actual commercial profits on commercial principles, and the issue had to be reconsidered on proper primary facts.

Ratio Decidendi: Under section 23A, only those assessment additions that truly reflect suppressed income or inflated expenditure can be treated as commercial profits, and a disallowed claim does not, by itself, prove distributable commercial profit.

---