Composite supply of health care services covers in-patient medicines and implants, preserving GST exemption for bundled treatment supplies.

Medicines, consumables and implants supplied to in-patients during diagnosis or treatment were treated as part of a composite supply of health care services. The ruling applied the principle that in-patient care ordinarily includes such items as naturally bundled and indispensable components of treatment, so they do not acquire an independent taxable character when supplied in conjunction with the principal health care service. As a result, the bundled supply follows the GST exemption applicable to health care services. Supplies not forming part of such integrated in-patient care may be taxed separately.

---

---

Issues: Whether medicines, consumables and implants supplied to in-patients during diagnosis or treatment form part of a composite supply of health care services and are eligible for exemption.

Analysis: Health care services provided by a clinical establishment are exempt under the GST exemption notification. In-patient care ordinarily includes lodging, nursing, medicines, consumables, implants, dietary food and similar facilities as part of the treatment package. These supplies are naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business and are supplied in conjunction with the principal supply of health care service. Where the medicines and allied items are indispensable to the treatment of in-patients, they do not assume an independent taxable character and remain ancillary to the dominant health care service.

Conclusion: The supply of medicines, consumables and implants to in-patients during diagnosis or treatment is a composite supply of health care services and is exempt.

Final Conclusion: Supplies integrally connected with in-patient treatment were held to be part of the exempt health care service, while the ruling accepted separate taxation only for supplies not forming part of such bundled in-patient care.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods and services are naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction with the principal health care service to in-patients, the entire supply takes the character of composite supply and follows the exemption applicable to the principal supply.

---