SSI exemption computation: exempt clearances under another notification may be included; penalty was deleted on settled precedent.

For SSI exemption under Notification No. 08/2003-CE, the value of goods cleared as exempt under Notification No. 05/2006-CE was required to be included in the aggregate value of clearances, as the Tribunal treated the issue as settled by earlier binding decisions upheld by higher forums. On that basis, the duty demand and interest were sustained against the assessee. On penalty, the Tribunal followed its earlier orders in the assessee's own case and found no reason to depart from the consistent view that penalties should be set aside. The penalty was therefore deleted, while the remand concerning waste and scrap remained undisturbed.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether, for availing SSI exemption under Notification No. 08/2003-CE dated 01.03.2003, the value of exempted goods cleared under Notification No. 05/2006-CE was to be included in the aggregate value of clearances; (ii) Whether the penalty imposed by the lower authorities was sustainable.

Issue (i): Whether, for availing SSI exemption under Notification No. 08/2003-CE dated 01.03.2003, the value of exempted goods cleared under Notification No. 05/2006-CE was to be included in the aggregate value of clearances.

Analysis: The controversy was held to be no longer res integra. The Tribunal noted that in the appellant's own case it had already been decided that the value of exempted goods cleared under Notification No. 05/2006-CE had to be included while computing the aggregate value of clearances for Notification No. 08/2003-CE. That view had been upheld by higher judicial forums. On that basis, the duty demand and interest were maintained.

Conclusion: The issue was decided against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.

Issue (ii): Whether the penalty imposed by the lower authorities was sustainable.

Analysis: The Tribunal followed its earlier orders in the assessee's own case, where penalties had been set aside on the same issue. No reason was found to depart from that consistent view.

Conclusion: The penalty was set aside and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The duty and interest demand was upheld, while the penalty was deleted and the remand concerning waste and scrap was left undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi: For SSI exemption computation, exempt clearances falling under another exemption notification can be included in the aggregate value of clearances where prior binding decisions have settled the issue; penalties may be set aside where consistent precedent so warrants.

---