Product classification turns on composition and intended use; Ayurvedic hair oil classification under Chapter 30 was sustained.

Hair oil classification for excise purposes depends on its composition, intended use and overall character rather than the label alone. On the facts, the product was used for dandruff, premature greying and split ends, and the Drug Controller and Licensing Authority had treated it as an Ayurvedic medicine. The appellate authority's finding that the goods belonged under Chapter 30, not as a cosmetic under Chapter 33, was supported by the record and earlier case-law considered by the parties. The Department failed to show any error in that classification analysis, so the Chapter 30 treatment was sustained and the departmental challenge rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether the hair oil was classifiable as an Ayurvedic medicine under Chapter 30 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 or as a cosmetic under Chapter 33, and whether the Department could displace the classification accepted by the Commissioner (Appeals).

Analysis: The competing classifications were examined in the light of the product ingredients, the intended use of the hair oil for dandruff, premature greying and split ends, the Drug Controller and Licensing Authority's treatment of the product as an Ayurvedic medicine, and the earlier circular and case-law relied upon by both sides. The record supported the view that similar hair oils had been classified differently depending on their composition and description, and the appellate authority had already analysed the material and placed the product under Chapter 30. No error was shown in that appreciation of the product's character.

Conclusion: The classification as an Ayurvedic product under Chapter 30 was upheld and the Department's challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The impugned order was sustained in full, with no interference warranted in the Departmental appeals.

Ratio Decidendi: Classification of a product for excise purposes must be determined on its composition, intended use and overall character, and a reasoned finding that the product is an Ayurvedic medicine will be sustained when the record supports that conclusion over a cosmetic classification.

---