Section 80-0 approval timing treated as directory where delay was administrative and relief remained available for the assessment year.

Section 80-0 was construed as a relief provision requiring governmental approval of a foreign technical collaboration agreement, but not expressly requiring that approval to be granted before 1 October of the assessment year. Because the assessee applied within time and could not control administrative delay, the timing requirement was treated as directory rather than mandatory. The later approval, made effective for the relevant assessment year, was therefore held to satisfy the statutory condition and preserve the deduction. The ruling treats the subsequent amendment as clarificatory of the original legislative intent.

---

---

Issues: Whether the requirement in section 80-0 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, that the Central Government's approval of the agreement with the foreign company be obtained before 1 October of the relevant assessment year was mandatory or directory, and whether approval granted after that date but with retrospective effect for the assessment year entitled the assessee to deduction.

Analysis: The provision was enacted to grant relief in respect of income from qualifying foreign technical collaboration agreements, while ensuring governmental approval of the agreement itself. The Court distinguished between the requirement of approval and the time by which approval had to be granted. It held that the statute did not expressly require that the approval be accorded before 1 October, and that such a reading would add words not found in the text. The assessee had applied within time and could not control administrative delay. Applying the object of the provision, the Court treated the timing requirement as directory and viewed the later amendment as clarificatory of the original legislative intent.

Conclusion: The approval obtained after 1 October, but made effective from the relevant assessment year, satisfied the statutory requirement, and the assessee was entitled to deduction under section 80-0.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a statutory approval provision is enacted to confer relief and the assessee has complied with the application requirement, the time for governmental approval may be construed as directory rather than mandatory if strict insistence on the date would defeat the object of the enactment and the approval is made effective for the relevant year.

---