Classification dispute under Chapter Headings 3814 and 3805.19 must be decided on merits, not set aside for alleged notice overreach.

The show cause notice itself covered manufacture of solvents and thinners under Chapter Heading 3814 and turpentine under Chapter Heading 3805.19, so the original adjudicating authority did not travel beyond the notice when it classified the product, described as a mixture of solvents, hydrocarbons and non-hydrocarbons, under Chapter Heading 3814 rather than as turpentine oil under Chapter Heading 3805.19. The Commissioner (Appeals) should therefore have examined the classification dispute on merits instead of setting aside the finding solely on the ground of alleged excess over the notice. The remand order was set aside and the matter was sent back to the Commissioner (Appeals) for decision on merits.

---

---

Issues: Whether the original adjudicating authority travelled beyond the scope of the show cause notice while classifying the product under Chapter Heading 3814.00 instead of Chapter Heading 3805.19, and whether the Commissioner (Appeals) was in remanding the matter without examining the classification dispute on merits.

Analysis: The show cause notice referred to manufacture of solvents and thinners under Chapter Heading 3814 as well as turpentine falling under Chapter Heading 3805.19. The original adjudicating authority gave reasons for treating the product, described as a mixture of different solvents, hydrocarbons and non-hydrocarbons, as classifiable under Chapter Heading 3814 and not as turpentine oil under Chapter Heading 3805.19. Since the notice itself covered goods falling under 3814, the finding could not be treated as being beyond the notice. The Commissioner (Appeals) therefore ought to have examined the classification issue on merits instead of setting aside the finding on the sole ground of alleged travel beyond the notice.

Conclusion: The remand order was set aside and the matter was remanded to the Commissioner (Appeals) for decision on the classification issue on merits. The revenue's appeal succeeded.

---