Taxable sale classification requires scrutiny of joint venture documents before treating aircraft share transfer as a sale.

Transfer of an interest in jointly owned aircraft under the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 required examination of the joint venture agreement, memorandum of agreement and surrounding documents to determine whether the transaction was a taxable sale or only a relinquishment of a share in the venture. An assessment that adopted the enforcement proposal verbatim, without independent consideration of the objections and documents, was found unsustainable on that footing. The finding characterising the transaction as a sale was set aside, and the assessment on that head was remanded for fresh consideration in accordance with law.

---

---

Issues: Whether the transfer of the petitioner's interest in the jointly owned aircraft constituted a "sale" within the meaning of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006, and whether the assessment on that head could be sustained without examining the joint venture documents and the parties' intention.

Analysis: The assessment order proceeded on the footing that the disposal of the aircraft was a taxable sale, but it did not examine the joint venture agreement, the memorandum of agreement, or the surrounding documents relied upon by the petitioner. The petitioner's case was that the transaction was only a relinquishment or release of its share in the joint venture, which required factual scrutiny to determine whether it answered the statutory definition of sale. The order also reflected a verbatim acceptance of the enforcement proposal, without independent consideration of the objections and documents.

Conclusion: The finding treating the transaction as a sale was set aside and the matter was remanded to the respondent for fresh consideration and re-doing of the assessment on that head in accordance with law.

---