Weight-based exemption for sachet packs under Rule 34 determined excise valuation under the general provision, not retail valuation.

Hair dye cleared in individual 6-gram sachets placed in a mono-carton fell within the Rule 34 exemption for packages containing less than 20 grams or 20 millilitres. The mono-carton arrangement did not negate that exemption, and the factual finding on sachet weight and packing pattern prevailed over the metrology opinion. As a result, the goods were treated as outside the packaged commodities regime and assessable under the general valuation provision in Section 4 of the Central Excise Act, 1944, rather than under Section 4A. The reasoning relied on the applicability of Krafttech Products to weight-based exemption in bundled retail packing.

---

---

Issues: Whether hair dye cleared in sachets packed in a mono-carton fell within Rule 34 of the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977 so as to be of those Rules, and consequently liable to assessment under Section 4 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 rather than Section 4A of that Act.

Analysis: The goods were cleared in individual sachets of 6 gms. each, with six sachets placed in one mono-carton. Rule 34, as applicable during the relevant time, excluded packages containing commodities of less than 20 grams or 20 millilitres when sold by weight or measure. On the factual finding that each sachet was of 6 gms., the condition of Rule 34 stood satisfied. The mono-carton arrangement did not deprive the package of the exemption, and the reasoning in Krafttech Products was treated as applicable. The metrology opinion was not accepted because the adjudicating authority's factual finding regarding sachet weight and packing pattern governed the issue.

Conclusion: The goods were covered by Rule 34 and were not subject to the packaged commodities regime. They were therefore assessable under Section 4 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and not under Section 4A of that Act.

Final Conclusion: The appeals succeeded, and the duty classification adopted by Revenue was set aside, with the penalty also falling along with the main relief.

Ratio Decidendi: Where individual units in a mono-carton satisfy the weight-based exemption under Rule 34, the package is of the packaged commodities rules and valuation must follow the general assessable value provision rather than the special retail sale valuation provision.

---