Cenvat credit on cargo and courier services turns on place of removal and sale terms, with remand for fresh consideration.

Cenvat credit on cargo and courier services used to dispatch finished goods depended on whether those services qualified as input services in light of the place of removal and the sale terms in the purchase orders. The Tribunal noted that the issue had been examined in an earlier decision and required reconsideration by the original authority with reference to that precedent and the relevant circular on determining place of removal. The penalty was not sustained at this stage because it had been set aside in the relied-upon final order. The matter was remanded for fresh decision on credit eligibility after hearing the appellant.

---

---

Issues: Whether Cenvat credit on cargo service and courier service used for dispatch of finished goods was admissible, and whether the demand, interest and penalty required fresh consideration.

Analysis: The dispute turned on whether the services used for dispatch of finished goods could be treated as input services having regard to the place of removal and the sale terms reflected in the purchase orders. The Tribunal noted that the issue had already been considered in another decision and that the matter required re-examination by the original authority in the light of that precedent and the relevant circular on determination of place of removal. As the penalty had been set aside in the relied-upon final order, the penalty in the present matter was also not sustained at this stage.

Conclusion: The appeal was allowed by way of remand and the matter was sent back to the original authority for fresh decision on eligibility of Cenvat credit after hearing the appellant.

---