Reasonable explanation for delayed declaration forms must be considered before denying concessional tax benefit and remand follows.

Concessional tax benefit linked to production of C and F declaration forms could not be denied without considering a reasonable explanation for delayed production. The assessee was entitled to place its reasons before the fact-finding forum, and the Tribunal erred in rejecting the claim without affording an effective opportunity. The matter was therefore remitted for fresh consideration on the limited question of the assessee's reasons for non-production of the forms at the proper stage.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee was entitled to an opportunity before the Tribunal to establish the reasons for not producing the C and F declaration forms within time and seek consideration of the claim for concessional levy of tax.

Analysis: The assessment was made ex parte because the declaratory forms were not produced. The appellate authorities declined relief on the ground that the assessee had not satisfactorily explained the failure to produce the forms earlier. The Court noted that entitlement to concessional levy could not be defeated merely for an inadvertent lapse where the law permits consideration of a reasonable explanation, and that the assessee should be allowed to substantiate the stated reasons before the fact-finding forum. Since the Tribunal had rejected the appeal without affording such an effective opportunity, a remand was considered appropriate in the interests of justice.

Conclusion: The assessee was entitled to an opportunity to establish the reasons for delayed production of the declaration forms, and the matter was required to be sent back to the Tribunal for that purpose.

Final Conclusion: The petitions succeeded and the dispute was remitted to the Tribunal for fresh consideration on the limited question of the assessee's reasons for non-production of the declaratory forms at the proper stage.

Ratio Decidendi: Where concessional tax benefit depends on production of declaration forms and the assessee seeks to explain non-production, a reasonable and substantiated explanation must be considered on merits and the matter may be remanded to afford such opportunity.

---