Trade discount and assessable value principles: genuine discount without flow-back is deductible, and unrelated machine usage charges are excluded.

Genuine trade discount is deductible when the factual finding shows no flow-back or return, because the discount is not a device to inflate value. Machine usage charges are not includable in assessable value where the vending machine is owned by one company but the charges are payable to another and do not form part of the price of the goods. On both valuation issues, the assessee prevailed and the departmental appeals were dismissed.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether the assessee was entitled to deduction on account of trade discount; (ii) whether machine usage charges formed part of the assessable value of the product.

Issue (i): whether the assessee was entitled to deduction on account of trade discount.

Analysis: The Tribunal had found as a fact that there was no flow back or return of the trade discount. That finding showed that the discount was genuine and not a device to inflate value.

Conclusion: The deduction for trade discount was allowable and the finding on this issue was left undisturbed.

Issue (ii): whether machine usage charges formed part of the assessable value of the product.

Analysis: The vending machine was installed by the holding company, but ownership vested in the marketing company. The charges were payable to the marketing company and not to the holding company, so they were not part of the value of the goods.

Conclusion: Machine usage charges were not includable in the assessable value.

Final Conclusion: The assessee succeeded on both valuation questions and the departmental appeals were dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi: Genuine trade discount without flow back is deductible, and charges not payable to the assessee and not forming part of the price of the goods are not includable in assessable value.

---