Marketable 32W lamp unit held outside anti-dumping coverage; declaration accepted and confiscation and penalty set aside.

Imported goods were found, on samples, photographs and market evidence, to be a marketable 32W unit made up of four U-shaped tubes operated as one lamp by a single PCB. On that factual basis, the declaration was accepted and the goods were treated as outside the product category covered by the relevant anti-dumping notification. As the notification did not apply to the imported article as presented, anti-dumping duty was not leviable. Confiscation and penalties based on alleged misdeclaration also could not survive and were set aside, with consequential relief following.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported goods were correctly declared as energy saving 32W 4 U-shaped tubes and, if so, whether anti-dumping duty under Notification No. 55/2009-Cus dated 26.05.2009, confiscation and penalty were sustainable.

Analysis: The imported item was found to be a combination of four U-tubes making a 32W unit, capable of being used as one lamp and operated by one PCB, and supported by the appellant's samples, photographs and market evidence. On that basis, the goods were treated as a marketable 32W product and not as the misdeclared item alleged by the department. Since the notification covered goods attracting anti-dumping duty in the relevant category, the Tribunal held that the imported goods did not fall within its ambit.

Conclusion: The declaration was accepted, no anti-dumping duty was leviable, and the confiscation and penalties were set aside.

Final Conclusion: The appeals succeeded and the impugned order was annulled with consequential relief.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the evidence shows that the imported article is a marketable 32W unit as presented, it cannot be treated as misdeclared or as falling within the anti-dumping notification applied to a different product category, and consequential confiscation and penalty cannot survive.

---