Duty exemption for defective replacement goods is confined to personal property imports and free manufacturer replacement conditions.

Notification No. 80/70 exempted duty only for defective articles previously brought into India as an individual's private personal property, and only where free repair or replacement was undertaken by the manufacturer through its agent or branch in India. The Tribunal applied its earlier view that the benefit does not extend to goods imported as the property of a firm or company, and that the free-of-charge condition must be satisfied. On that basis, the exemption was held inapplicable to the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee was entitled to the benefit of Notification No. 80/70 dated 29-8-1970 for imported replacement goods alleged to be defective articles returned for free replacement or repair.

Analysis: The notification exempted duty only in respect of defective articles previously brought into India and which were private personal property of the importer. The Tribunal relied on its earlier view that the benefit is confined to goods imported as replacement of an individual's personal property and not the property of a firm or company. It also noted that repair or replacement must be undertaken free of charge by the manufacturer through his agent or branch in India, and that the benefit is unavailable where this condition is not satisfied.

Conclusion: The exemption was not admissible to the assessee.

---